A New York proposal would make knowingly or recklessly relying on fabricated legal authority in a ruling explicit judicial misconduct. Judges could face discipline or referral to lawmakers for possible impeachment.
Sen. Michelle Hinchey introduced S10741 on Nov. 16. It remains in the Senate Rules Committee.
The bill would cover written decisions and orders, including invented sources and material misrepresentations of real ones. Material errors would be those capable of affecting legal analysis, a case's outcome or a party's substantial rights. AI use alone would not constitute misconduct.
Safeguards would exclude findings based solely on good-faith interpretations of unsettled law and immaterial typos or citation-format errors. The commission would consider verification practices, training, repetition, prompt corrections and effects on the case when assessing culpability and sanctions.
Its impeachment provision would allow a referral to the Assembly speaker for consideration. A referral would not itself remove a judge. If enacted, the measure would take effect after 180 days and apply prospectively.
What judges already have to do

New York's interim court-system AI policy, effective in October 2025, already places responsibility for opinions and orders on judges. They cannot delegate the judicial decisions they are ethically required to make.
The policy applies to judges and nonjudicial employees, including court work on personal devices. It requires approved generative AI products and initial training before use. Users must review generated content and correct inaccuracies or bias. Even AI features in established legal research services require independent verification. Approval of a product addresses technological safety and does not establish that it is suitable for every task.
The policy also restricts what can be uploaded to AI systems outside court control. That includes confidential information and documents filed in court, even when those documents are public.
Those requirements address how court employees use the technology. Hinchey's proposal would add a specific statutory misconduct standard for the resulting written rulings.
Separate court rules for lawyers and parties permit AI-assisted preparation of filings within existing professional duties. The rules say routine disclosure of AI use should not be required. Their model rule requires independent review for fabricated cases, statutes and other material. Signing the paper certifies that review. These rules concern submissions to a court; the bill concerns writings issued or adopted by a judge.
How common judicial AI use is
A March survey published by the New York City Bar Association found that more than 60% of responding federal judges had used an AI tool in judicial work. About 22% reported weekly or daily use, and legal research was the most common task.
The researchers received 112 responses from a random sample of 502 federal judges, a 22.3% response rate. That is evidence about the respondents, not a count of New York state judges or proof that any judge issued a faulty ruling. The survey also found that legal-specific tools were used more frequently than general-purpose chatbots.
A complaint cannot overturn a ruling

New York's Commission on Judicial Conduct already investigates ethical misconduct. Its possible public determinations include admonition, censure and removal, subject to review by the state's Court of Appeals. Judges have 30 days after service of a determination to request that review. Investigations generally remain confidential until a public misconduct determination, unless the judge makes the process public.
The commission's jurisdiction does not extend to federal judges. It cannot reverse a decision, order a new trial, give legal advice or represent a litigant. Dissatisfaction with a result, by itself, does not establish misconduct.
The commission's complaint guidance also warns that an investigation will not transfer a case to another judge or change a ruling. There is no expedited emergency investigation. It directs people seeking to challenge a ruling to consult an attorney about appeal rights.












