A federal grand jury indicted West Virginia State Auditor Mark Hunt and four other people in a case involving tax deeds for nine properties and a separate set of bank fraud allegations. Federal prosecutors announced the charges Monday, Nov. 16. They say Hunt used his office to issue deeds to benefit a longtime friend and business associate after staff determined the properties did not qualify for transfer.
The properties are in Kanawha and Boone counties. Prosecutors say a business associated with Robert Lisle Johns sought to buy them through the state's delinquent tax process. Employees in the auditor's land division concluded the purchaser had missed deadlines for required payments and paperwork, according to the U.S. attorney's office. The office says Hunt signed eight deeds on March 28, 2025, and the ninth on June 6, 2025, over staff objections.
Hunt, Johns, deputy chief of staff David Keith Cole and general counsel Frederic Scott Caudill each face nine counts of theft of property. Johns became special counsel at the auditor's office in June 2025. Cole and Caudill each also face a count of making false statements to federal investigators.
What a tax sale buyer has to do before getting a deed

The state law on tax lien sales generally gives a purchaser 120 days from the auditor's approval of the sale to identify who must get a notice and cover the cost of giving that notice. For certain residential properties, the purchaser also has to provide the property's mailing address. Missing the requirements can cost the purchaser the benefits of the sale. The law allows a limited extension for the notice requirements if the purchaser applies and pays the required fee.
The notice gives eligible owners and others with an interest in the property a chance to redeem it by paying what is owed. State law sets a minimum period before a deputy commissioner can issue a deed. The U.S. attorney's office alleges the nine deeds were issued despite missed requirements. Its announcement did not report a court ruling on ownership of the properties.
Separate charges concern state wages
Prosecutors also allege that auditor's office employee Marie Ann Hoffmann recorded time spent at Hunt's private law firm as hours worked for the state. They say Cole approved the timecards with Hunt's knowledge and that the state paid Hoffmann for the hours through its designated bank. Hunt and Cole face charges of aiding and abetting the alleged bank fraud.
Hunt took office in January 2025. The indictments contain allegations, and all five defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.




