The Federal Bureau of Prisons could not tell auditors how many families learned from the agency that a relative had died in federal custody, or whether officials notified them on time. The bureau recorded 3,585 deaths in its facilities from fiscal 2016 through fiscal 2025. Its policy required staff to notify emergency contacts and next of kin, according to a Government Accountability Office report released Monday, Nov. 16.

Bureau records listed 2,997 of those deaths as natural. Auditors took a closer look at 244 deaths classified as natural or of unknown manner in fiscal 2024. The bureau’s investigation records identified shortcomings in medical care in 111 cases, about 45 percent. Those included delays getting people to outside appointments, tests that staff did not order, and deficiencies in emergency responses. Some of the shortcomings contributed to deaths, the GAO said. The 45 percent figure counts cases where a review identified a problem with care, regardless of whether the problem contributed to the death.

What families are supposed to hear

Entrance to U.S. Penitentiary Allenwood in Pennsylvania
A Federal Bureau of Prisons file photograph of U.S. Penitentiary Allenwood in Pennsylvania, first archived in 2014.Federal Bureau of Prisons / U.S. public domain

Bureau policy calls for prison staff to telephone designated emergency contacts immediately after a death and to send the next of kin a condolence letter as soon as practical, according to the full audit. In interviews at three facilities, auditors found differing accounts of what staff record. Two facilities said they had no local requirement to document family notifications. A third said it logged its attempts to reach the next of kin and recorded whether they succeeded.

In May, the bureau began requiring staff to document attempts to reach the next of kin. GAO found two remaining gaps. The policy leaves calls to emergency contacts outside that tracking requirement and does not require managers to check whether notifications took place. The audit recommends recording the time and method for attempts to reach both groups, including calls that did not connect.

The bureau also directs staff to explain what happened. Its policy leaves the details of that explanation undefined. Officials told auditors those details could include the manner of death, where it occurred, or what happened beforehand. Families may need more than one conversation because those facts can become available after the initial call. GAO said some staff failed to pass along details when they did have them, and recommended that managers check whether staff provide the information both initially and as it becomes available.

What prison reviews found

A prison can make recommendations after reviewing a death at its facility. The bureau’s central office tracks recommendations from subsequent physician reviews and more detailed investigations into underlying causes. In 42 of the fiscal 2024 cases GAO examined, the prison recommended changes and the secondary physician review contained no recommendations. Headquarters had no record of those local recommendations or whether the prison carried them out.

One facility found that a patient with an abnormal ultrasound never received a recommended follow-up scan and moved to another prison without a plan for continuing care. The facility recommended changes. Those recommendations went unrecorded at headquarters because they were absent from the physician’s secondary review and the bureau performed no separate root cause analysis. The bureau told auditors that its physician reviews generally pick up the most serious issues. GAO recommended that headquarters also record recommendations from facilities and whether the facilities put them into practice.

A separate Justice Department inspector general review in 2024 also called for better tracking of follow-up recommendations. That review examined deaths attributed to suicide, homicide, accident or unknown factors. The new audit examines how the bureau reviews natural deaths and keeps families informed.

What happens next

U.S. Department of Justice building entrance in Washington, D.C.
An entrance to the U.S. Department of Justice in Washington, D.C., in February 2025.G. Edward Johnson / CC BY 4.0

The Bureau of Prisons agreed with all 13 GAO recommendations, including clearer family notices and help obtaining medical records. GAO lists the recommendations as open. Families seeking a relative’s medical records generally must use the bureau’s public records request process, according to the audit. GAO found that requests could take months and recommended that the bureau give families clearer written information about records, the investigation and how to arrange the transfer of remains and personal property.