A federal audit released Monday, Nov. 16, urges Congress to give tribal governments more say over who investigates and prosecutes certain crimes on their lands. The Government Accountability Office says tribes should be able to ask the federal government to take back criminal jurisdiction that states acquired under Public Law 280. It also says states should need tribal consent before offering to return that authority.
Congress enacted Public Law 280 in 1953. It shifted authority over many criminal cases from federal officials to certain states. In areas covered by the law, tribal governments generally share authority with state governments over certain offenses involving tribal citizens. The details vary with the offense, the people involved and the location. The GAO says about 65 percent of the country’s 575 federally recognized tribes are located in the six states named in the law. That figure includes Alaska. The new audit examined how the law works in the lower 48 states and drew on fieldwork in California, Nebraska and Oregon.
Who can start a transfer today

Federal law gives states the authority to offer to return jurisdiction to the federal government. The Interior secretary can accept an offer covering all or part of that authority. The transfer is called retrocession. A tribal government currently has no way to initiate that process directly with the federal government under Public Law 280. A state can also make an offer without securing consent from the affected tribe.
Some tribes can start the discussion through state law. Oregon and Washington let tribal governments submit a formal request to their governor. A state still has to make the offer and the federal government has to accept it. Washington went through that process with the Yakama Nation. The tribal government petitioned in 2012, Washington offered to return part of its authority in 2014, and the federal acceptance took full effect in April 2016. The agreement covered part of Washington’s civil and criminal authority. That case illustrates how a transfer can change authority in one area while leaving other responsibilities with the state.
What changes when a state steps back
Tribal leaders in two communities told auditors that returning authority had given their governments more control over public safety and helped resolve problems with county law enforcement. State officials in two states raised another concern. A tribal government without its own police, courts or corrections programs could lose access to state services if the state returns its authority. The audit says some tribal and local agencies address overlapping jurisdiction now through shared arrangements, such as allowing tribal officers to exercise certain powers of county deputies.
The full GAO report estimates that the Bureau of Indian Affairs spent about $150 million on public safety and justice for tribes in the five mandatory states in the lower 48 from fiscal 2017 through 2021. That was about 5 percent of the $2.8 billion the bureau estimated those tribes needed for those services. The comparison covers funding from that agency. The Justice Department makes separate competitive grants, and the audit found those grants generally provided more per person to tribes in the mandatory states than to tribes elsewhere in the lower 48 over a different period, fiscal 2017 through 2024.
What Congress would have to change

Under the first recommendation, a tribal government could initiate a transfer. Once Interior accepted it, the federal government would take over the criminal authority the state had exercised under the law. Tribal governments would keep their own authority. The second recommendation would require tribal consent before a state could offer to return that authority. GAO lists both as open recommendations to Congress. Existing jurisdiction still depends on the offense, where it happened, and the laws and agreements that apply there.







