A federal judge in Brooklyn heard arguments Monday on whether to approve a proposed Visa and Mastercard settlement that could lower some of the fees U.S. merchants pay to take credit cards. U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan ended the hearing without ruling. Stores still face their current card acceptance rules and fee schedules.

The court-authorized notice scheduled the hearing for 11 a.m. Eastern on Monday. The case began in 2005 over allegations that the card networks and banks used their rules to keep fees high. Cogan gave preliminary approval to the revised deal in June. A different judge rejected an earlier agreement in 2024, according to Visa’s SEC filing.

The proposed agreement changes what merchants would pay and which cards they could accept. The $38 billion often associated with the deal is an estimate of what merchants could save through 2031 from changes to the rules. Economists retained by the merchants who negotiated the deal made that estimate. The agreement provides no cash payments to class members.

Which fees would fall

Close-up of a credit card chip and a contactless payment symbol.
A credit card chip and contactless symbol, photographed in May 2017.kuhnmi · CC BY 2.0

The settlement terms would cap posted interchange rates for standard consumer credit cards at 1.25% for eight years. At that rate, the interchange portion of a $100 purchase would be $1.25. A merchant’s full processing bill can include other charges, so the cap does not set the total cost of accepting that purchase. Premium rewards and commercial credit cards are outside that standard-card cap.

The two networks would also have to lower their average effective credit card interchange rates by at least 0.10 percentage point from a shared baseline for five years. The baseline is weighted by card volume across both networks for the year ended March 31, 2025. That requirement applies to an average across transactions, where the mix of cards matters. It does not guarantee the same reduction on each sale. Businesses with custom interchange agreements would get proportional reductions on those covered transactions under a separate provision.

Which cards stores could take

A card payment terminal attached to a supermarket self-checkout station.
A supermarket self-checkout terminal, photographed in June 2021.Anselm Schüler · CC BY-SA 4.0

A store could choose among three groups of credit cards: standard consumer, premium consumer and commercial. It could accept standard cards from one network but decline that network’s premium cards, for instance, or make a different choice for Visa than for Mastercard. Newly issued premium and commercial cards would carry markings that help merchants identify the groups. The proposed choice is generally by category, so accepting one premium card while refusing an equivalent card from another bank would still be constrained.

Where state law allows a surcharge, the proposal would give merchants more flexibility to add one on Visa or Mastercard credit cards. A store could apply it across a network or to a particular credit card product. The cap would be 3% or the merchant’s acceptance cost, whichever is lower.

Some large retailers and trade groups argue that the changes would leave fees too high on rewards cards customers expect to use. The Retail Industry Leaders Association, which filed an objection with the National Retail Federation, also argues that the deal leaves too little room for merchants to challenge the fee structure in future litigation. Lawyers defending the agreement told the court Monday that the new acceptance options would substantially change the networks’ relationships with merchants.

What happens to older cash claims

The court is weighing future card rules in this agreement. Merchants who already filed for cash over earlier fees can check the separate payment settlement site. That case covers eligible U.S. merchants who accepted Visa or Mastercard from Jan. 1, 2004, through Jan. 25, 2019. Its claim deadline was Feb. 4, 2025. Monday’s hearing left that claims process separate and did not open a new filing window.