Amazon’s Black Friday sale starts Thursday, Nov. 19. Before buying, check the lowest price you can find for the same product in the past month. That number answers a different question from the crossed-out figure next to the sale price. A report released Monday and Amazon’s response show why the choice of comparison matters.

The Groundwork Collaborative report looked at 351 products that Amazon promoted during four Black Friday and Cyber Monday events in 2024 and 2025. The advocacy group found that 29.1% of the products had a sale-event price that matched or exceeded their lowest recorded price in the preceding 30 days. In 9.4% of cases, the sale-event price was higher than the earlier low. Those percentages describe the products in the study. Groundwork did not sample the entire marketplace or measure prices for this week’s sale.

Why the two price checks disagree

Brown Amazon Prime Now delivery bags
Amazon Prime Now delivery bags in October 2015.goblinbox_(queen_of_ad_hoc_bento) / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 2.0

Groundwork got its historical prices from Keepa, a service that records changes on Amazon product pages. The researchers picked out the lowest recorded price during the event and compared it with the lowest recorded price in the weeks before it. They required a price observation during the event and in the 10 days leading up to it. Their sample came from products Amazon featured, so it was especially useful for examining how prices on promoted items had moved.

In its response, Amazon said some items in the report did not carry an on-site deal badge, some prices were recorded incorrectly and some discounts started early and stayed in place during the event. The company said its own review found 98% of the deals it assessed were at or below the past month’s price. It acknowledged a corporate blog had described a small number of items as deals even though the store had never given them badges. Amazon says the blog listings were subject to change.

An early discount is where the two methods can give a shopper different answers. If a price drops before the event and stays there, a shopper who waited gets the same price as someone who bought early. Groundwork ran a separate calculation dropping the week before each event from the comparison. In that calculation, roughly one in five offers still matched or exceeded the earlier low. Amazon says the exact time a price drops matters when determining whether it qualifies as an early deal.

What the crossed-out price can tell you

Amazon says a crossed-out List Price generally reflects a manufacturer’s suggested retail price. It also uses a Typical Price as a reference for some offers. A deal badge is a separate label. Amazon says a product needs a validated reference price and, generally, a deal price at or below its lowest price in the previous 30 days to get the badge.

Say a product costs $80 today and the crossed-out price is $100. The displayed discount would be 20%. If that same version sold for $80 two weeks ago, today’s price ties the earlier offer. If it sold for $75, today’s offer costs $5 more. Those examples use hypothetical prices. For a real comparison, use the exact model number and check capacity, size, condition and what comes in the box.

Check the offer you can actually buy

A shopper holds a card while using a laptop
An online shopper using a laptop in October 2022.Shixart1985 / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 2.0

Amazon’s sale announcement says shoppers can open Price history on a product page or ask Alexa for Shopping for up to 365 days of price data. Start with the last month, then look farther back if you can wait for another dip. Check who sells the item and what you will pay after shipping and any coupon or membership requirement. A price history can help you set a target, while the seller and checkout total tell you whether an available offer meets it. See the holiday sale calendar and return considerations if you’re comparing different stores this week.