District attorneys from 29 California counties, along with victims' families, police officers and prosecutors' groups, have asked the California Supreme Court to stop Gov. Gavin Newsom from commuting the state's 548 death sentences. Their petition for a writ of mandate, dated Nov. 15, asks the court for an immediate stay while it decides the case.

Newsom announced on Nov. 5 that he would change every death sentence in California to life in prison without parole. Edit USA covered that announcement when it was made.

The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, a Sacramento legal group whose president is Anne Marie Schubert, filed the case with the California District Attorneys Association. The foundation announced the lawsuit on Nov. 16.

The petitioners ask for four things:

  • An immediate order telling the governor and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to halt the commutations until the court rules.
  • An order requiring the state to show why permanent relief shouldn't be granted.
  • A ruling that any commutation granted without the required notice, without the required review for people twice convicted of a felony, or as a mass grant is void.
  • An order keeping everyone on the list in custody as death-sentenced prisoners in the state's records.

The copy posted by the foundation shows no case number yet, and the court had not posted a response as of Tuesday.

The legal fight over notice

Gov. Gavin Newsom smiling in a navy suit and tie in front of a red and white flag
California Gov. Gavin Newsom in September 2025.UK Government / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 4.0

California's Constitution gives the governor the power to commute sentences, but "subject to application procedures provided by statute." The petition leans on that phrase. It says a 2011 state law requires district attorneys to get notice before a commutation so victims' families can weigh in, and that none of the district attorneys was notified.

Newsom's office reads the law differently. According to the petition, the governor's Explanatory Statement argues that those procedures regulate people who apply for clemency and do not limit a governor acting on his own.

The petition also points to the governor's own description of how he decided. It quotes his statement that he "did not consider information about their individual circumstances," other than the death sentence and whether a person had two felony convictions. The petitioners say a mass grant like that falls outside his power.

The Supreme Court's separate role

The stone facade of the Earl Warren Building in San Francisco with a California flag flying above the entrance
The Earl Warren Building in San Francisco, home of the California Supreme Court, in August 2024.Marincyclist / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0

Some of the 548 cases have to go through the Supreme Court regardless. The state Constitution requires four justices to recommend clemency for anyone twice convicted of a felony. The petition says Newsom sent the court 382 such cases at once and asked for quick consideration.

The petitioners claim his list contains errors. They point to at least two prisoners they say have a second felony conviction but were left out of the cases sent to the court, and they ask that commutations for everyone not referred be put on hold until the records are checked. They say they will raise the twice-convicted issue in a separate filing in the court's recommendation matter, S299513.

Newsom's fact sheet says the commutations would not release anyone, make anyone eligible for parole or change any conviction. California's last execution was on Jan. 17, 2006.