Federal agencies must get approval from two White House offices before their employees agree to appear before any congressional committee, according to a Nov. 16 memo from White House Counsel William O. Scharf. The instruction covers executive departments as well as agencies and names the White House Office of Legislative Affairs and the Office of the White House Counsel.
The memo, addressed to executive branch general counsels, says both offices need advance notice and must give approval before agency personnel agree to testify. Scharf describes this as an established consultation process. The one-page document gives no timeline for the offices to answer and says further guidance on other engagements with Congress is forthcoming.
What happens when a committee invites a witness?

The immediate effect is on the answer an agency can give to an invitation. A committee might invite an official to explain how the agency spent money Congress appropriated, how it administered a benefits program or why it changed a rule. Under the memo, the agency needs both White House offices to approve the appearance before its employee can agree.
Congress can use testimony and records both to examine how laws are being carried out and to decide whether to write new ones. The Congressional Research Service’s overview of oversight explains that committees have formal investigative tools, while individual lawmakers generally have to seek voluntary cooperation from agency officials or other witnesses. The memo applies to appearances before committees. It leaves other contacts for the promised guidance.
What if the committee issues a subpoena?
A subpoena is a formal demand for testimony or records. The applicable chamber and committee rules govern who can issue one. The research service says some committees authorize their chairs to act, while others require additional steps. The White House memo addresses when an employee may agree to appear. It gives no instructions on subpoenas and identifies no hearing or witness affected by the policy.
A dispute over a subpoena can lead to negotiations between Congress and the executive branch. The Congressional Oversight Manual describes how the branches may negotiate over the information sought and what an agency can provide. Committees also have enforcement options, including seeking a court order, according to the research service. Courts generally require a valid legislative purpose for congressional investigative demands. An internal approval rule and a committee’s authority to compel testimony are separate questions.
Monday’s instruction follows Scharf’s warning last week to Rep. Robert Garcia, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee, over how Democrats might use subpoenas after the midterms. That letter set out the White House’s view of the legal limits on congressional demands. The memo is directed inward, to agency lawyers who handle requests for appearances. Its first practical test will be how the two offices handle individual hearing invitations.












