Gov. Kathy Hochul vetoed New York's Food Safety and Chemical Disclosure Act on Friday, November 20, stopping a proposed state ban on three food additives and a new ingredient-disclosure system. The legislative record for S1239-F lists the measure as vetoed.

The FDA's nationwide Red No. 3 phaseout still has a food-manufacturing deadline in January. California has a separate law taking effect that month. Neither deadline depends on New York adopting this bill.

What Hochul rejected

The bill would have prohibited food containing FD&C Red No. 3, potassium bromate or propylparaben. It covered manufacture and commercial distribution as well as sale, with transitional provisions for certain existing stock.

It also would have required reports to New York's Department of Agriculture and Markets on certain substances companies classify as generally recognized as safe, or GRAS. A public database would have carried the information. The final bill's sponsor memo describes exemptions, including for certain substances and small businesses, and says the measure would create no new food-labeling requirements.

The veto means these proposed New York requirements do not take effect through this legislation. It does not repeal the separate federal or California rules.

Why the governor vetoed it

A plain bagel on a white background
A plain bagel purchased in Brooklyn, photographed October 30, 2010. Its flour additives are not documented.Photo: Evan-Amos / Wikimedia Commons / Public domain.

In her November 20 veto memorandum, Hochul argued that food-ingredient oversight belongs at the federal level. She said a state reporting database would cost millions of dollars that were not included in New York's financial plan and would burden the agriculture department.

She also argued that banning bromated flour would force pizza and bagel makers to change recipes and production methods, with possible higher costs. That is the governor's prediction, not an established price increase resulting from the veto.

Her memo points to the FDA's Red No. 3 action and its proposed GRAS changes as reasons to pursue federal oversight.

The deadlines that still apply

Two red velvet cupcakes with white frosting
Red velvet cupcakes photographed in September 2026. Color does not identify which dye, if any, was used.Photo: Ralff Nestor Nacor / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0.

The FDA's current Red No. 3 guidance distinguishes food from ingested drugs. California's Department of Education separately confirms the state's January 2027 restrictions.

RuleDateScope
California Food Safety ActJan. 1, 2027Food products containing Red dye 3, potassium bromate, propylparaben or brominated vegetable oil
FDA Red No. 3 food phaseoutJan. 15, 2027Manufacturers must reformulate food using the dye
FDA Red No. 3 ingested-drug phaseoutJan. 18, 2028Manufacturers must reformulate ingested drugs using the dye

California's statute covers making and selling food in commerce. It permits civil penalties of up to $5,000 for a first violation and $10,000 for each later violation. A business selling food in California still has to follow that state's rules, regardless of New York's decision.

The federal dates are reformulation deadlines. The FDA says a product made before the applicable effective date could remain on the market afterward. Finding Red No. 3 on a package after January 15 therefore does not, by itself, establish that the product was manufactured in violation of the rule.

The agency requires the dye in a food's ingredient statement, where it may be listed as FD&C Red No. 3, Red 3 or FD&C Red 3. Product color alone cannot identify it.

The FDA's action follows the Delaney Clause, which bars authorization of a food or color additive found to cause cancer in humans or animals. Its January 2025 explanation cites cancer in male rats at high exposure levels through a rat-specific hormonal mechanism. It says there is no evidence showing Red No. 3 causes cancer in humans.

Ingredient disclosure remains a separate issue

GRAS status concerns whether a substance's intended use is exempt from food-additive premarket approval. The FDA explains that the exemption depends on qualified experts generally recognizing the use as adequately shown to be safe.

Under the current federal notification system, companies may reach a GRAS conclusion without notifying the agency. The FDA's August proposal would require notices for certain uses, subject to exceptions. A proposal does not itself impose those new requirements.

The FDA's economic analysis says mandatory notices would give the agency more information to assess ingredients and supporting safety evidence. That federal disclosure project is distinct from the Red No. 3 deadlines. For a packaged food, the ingredient statement remains the place to check whether Red No. 3 is listed.