If your job-based health plan tells you a doctor is in network and you later get billed at out-of-network rates, you may be able to have the charge reduced. Federal law limits what plans can charge you for otherwise covered care when you relied on the plan’s incorrect network information. A Labor Department enforcement alert issued Friday, Nov. 13, reminds employers and health plans how that protection is supposed to work.

The alert comes as workers are comparing health plans for next year. The department’s benefits agency checked more than 27,000 providers across 27 networks while reviewing 37 plans. On average, 36 percent of the provider listings it checked had inaccurate information, such as a wrong phone number, address, specialty or network status. That figure describes the plans the agency checked. It includes errors that can make an appointment harder to book even when the office participates in the plan.

Before you choose a plan or book a visit

Two staff members work at computers in an appointment booking office.
Staff work in the military appointment booking office at Joint Base San Antonio, Texas, in July 2023.Jason W. Edwards / U.S. Department of Defense · Public domain

Look up the doctor or clinic using the exact plan and network name shown in your enrollment materials or member portal. Insurers can sell plans with different networks under the same brand. For a provider who works in several offices, check the address where you expect to be seen. For care that involves a separate facility, ask about the facility as well as the clinician.

If you are already enrolled, call the number on your insurance card to verify network status and ask for the answer in writing, by email or on paper. Under the federal rules for group plans, the plan or insurer must send a written response within one business day of a telephone request and keep a copy for at least two years. Save the response or a dated screenshot of the directory listing so you can show what the plan told you before the visit.

Then ask the office whether it is taking new patients on that plan. A correct network listing can still lead to a closed appointment book. In its spot checks, the department looked for an office that answered the phone or returned a voicemail, offered the listed specialty, participated in the plan, accepted new patients and could see one within 30 days. About three-quarters of the mental health and substance use disorder providers it checked missed at least one of those conditions.

If the bill is already here

A doctor discusses an X-ray with two people.
A doctor discusses an X-ray in a 2008 National Cancer Institute photograph.Rhoda Baer / National Cancer Institute · Public domain

Compare the bill with the explanation of benefits from your plan. Look at how the plan classified the provider or facility, what it covered and what it says you owe. If the plan applied out-of-network rates after its directory or its staff told you the provider was in network, send the plan the listing or written response together with the date of care. Ask it to reprocess the claim at the in-network rate. If it refuses, ask for its reason in writing and how to appeal.

For otherwise covered services that qualify, the plan cannot charge more in cost sharing than it would for in-network care. It must also apply your share to the applicable in-network deductible or out-of-pocket maximum. If you already paid a provider more than the in-network amount in a case covered by the law, the provider must refund the excess with interest. Keep the bill and proof of payment when you ask for that refund.

Plans and insurers are supposed to verify directories at least every 90 days and update them within two business days after a provider reports a change. If an outdated listing kept you from finding care, report that to the plan or the benefits office, too. The Labor Department recommends tracking complaints because they can reveal problems that routine directory checks miss.

For help with a private-sector job-based plan, contact the Employee Benefits Security Administration at 866-444-3272. The federal No Surprises Help Desk takes questions and complaints at 800-985-3059.