Oklahoma homeowners with certain State Farm Fire and Casualty claims for wind or hail damage occurring from 2021 through 2025 will get an opportunity for independent review under a settlement announced Nov. 13.

The Oklahoma Insurance Department's settlement page describes a $35 million consumer fund within a $47.86 million agreement. Being eligible for review does not guarantee a check.

Which claims may qualify

Close view of damaged roof shingles with torn and lifted edges
Shingle damage attributed by the photographer to installation and age. Archive photograph from Sept. 15, 2016.Sandul1234 / CC BY-SA 4.0

The department identifies Oklahoma State Farm homeowners policies and storm losses dated Jan. 1, 2021, through Dec. 31, 2025. The relevant wind or hail component must have been closed without payment.

OID says its eligibility description includes people who received partial payments or whose damage was assessed below their deductible. The agreement specifically identifies the wind/hail component, State Farm's Cause of Loss 35, as closed without payment. People who received some money should check their notice or ask OID about their particular claim.

Claims already resolved by settlement or final judgment for the same roof loss are excluded, as are claims withdrawn before State Farm decided whether to pay.

Follow the deadline in your notice

State Farm must send initial notices before Dec. 31, 2026. The agreement gives eligible customers 180 days after issuance of their initial notice to request review. Dec. 31 is a notice deadline, not a single opt-in deadline for all homeowners.

Supporting documents are not required to elect participation. The administrator can request them during review.

OID's Nov. 13 announcement says the independent administrator will examine the original claim file and additional evidence supplied by the homeowner. Its consumer page lists receipts and professional inspections among useful supporting records. Photos and estimates can also be considered in assessing the loss. Follow the instructions in the notice rather than submitting personal information through an unsolicited offer.

What accepting payment would release

The agreement requires a release covering claims against State Farm connected to the reviewed loss and the review program. People already litigating an eligible claim can participate, but receiving approved payment requires dismissal of the related litigated claims with prejudice.

The federal courts' glossary defines dismissal with prejudice as preventing an identical lawsuit from being filed later. Homeowners with pending litigation should discuss the release with their attorney before accepting payment.

The written payment determination starts another clock: 30 days after receipt to execute the release. Otherwise the offer is withdrawn, subject to a limited hardship extension.

Where the $47.86 million goes

The department's announcement divides the agreement into three parts:

PurposeAmount
Consumer claims review and restitutionAt least $35 million
Strengthen Oklahoma Homes roof-fortification program$10 million
Fines and examination expenses paid to OID$2.86 million

The full settlement amount is not a pool divided equally among policyholders. The department says an approved claim will be paid under that customer's policy. If the initial consumer funding is insufficient, OID and State Farm will agree on additional funding.

The examination found improperly denied or unpaid roof repairs, according to OID. State Farm disputes the findings and denies wrongdoing in the agreement.

Roof-fortification grants have a separate process

A roofer replacing shingles on a home in Norman, Oklahoma
A roofer repairs storm damage in Norman, Oklahoma, on June 22, 2010. Archive photograph.Patsy Lynch/FEMA / Public domain

The Strengthen Oklahoma Homes program funds wind and hail mitigation for owner-occupied, primary-residence single-family homes. It requires a FORTIFIED roof designation and has its own application and evaluation requirements. Its grants do not cover the evaluator's fee. Applicants must have a home in good repair and current homeowners and wind insurance. Flood insurance is required in a special flood hazard area.

A claims-review notice does not itself award a fortification grant. Use the program's OID page for those application instructions.

OID asks homeowners to verify settlement messages through official department or State Farm contacts and avoid giving sensitive information to unsolicited callers. The department's consumer assistance number is 800-522-0071.