Social Security's new annual financial report leaves a problem unresolved for people asked to repay benefits: the agency's controls over recorded overpayment balances still have a significant deficiency.
The agency announced the fiscal 2026 report on November 19, celebrating its 33rd consecutive clean financial-statement opinion and the repair of a longstanding information-system control issue. Commissioner Frank Bisignano's response to the auditors also acknowledges the separate overpayment finding.
A clean opinion means the financial statements passed the audit's standard for fair presentation. It does not certify each repayment demand sent to a beneficiary, cancel a debt or change the amount someone is entitled to receive.
What the auditors found

Ernst & Young's independent audit, dated November 13, tested a statistical sample of outstanding balances in the retirement, survivors and disability insurance program's overpayment ledger. It found calculation errors in 15.3% of sampled items.
That percentage describes errors in the sampled debt balances. It is not a finding that 15.3% of all Social Security payments, beneficiaries or repayment notices were wrong. The projected dollar effect was not large enough to materially misstate the financial statements.
The auditors did not run a comparable sample for Supplemental Security Income because its detailed debtor records and summary accounts remained unreconciled. They also identified computer-system limits on tracking very long repayment arrangements.
Ernst & Young classifies the combined overpayment-control problem as a significant deficiency, a category below a material weakness that still warrants management attention. Its recommendations include better documentation, reviews of manual calculations and checks that corrections were actually made.
What SSA says it fixed

The information-system deficiency highlighted in the announcement concerns a different part of the agency's financial controls. SSA says it fully remedied that longstanding finding for the first time since fiscal 2009.
Bisignano's signed response welcomes the unmodified financial-statement opinion, effective financial-reporting controls and the absence of reportable noncompliance in the areas tested. The same letter says the auditors continued to identify the benefit-overpayment deficiency and that the agency would keep working on payment accuracy.
The inspector general's management-challenges chapter adds context about collection costs. It summarizes a May 2026 review estimating that SSA spent $4.6 million pursuing nearly 16,000 small overpayments totaling about $2.6 million.
The chapter says SSA revised its cost-effectiveness policy in September, directing staff to end collection when further costs would likely exceed recoveries. That is an existing agency policy described in the report, not a new November debt-forgiveness program or a promise that any particular balance will be waived.
The chapter also summarizes an August 2026 SSI review that estimated employees had not taken required steps to pay 1.1 million underpayments totaling $291 million. Those projected findings come from an earlier audit and do not identify an amount owed to any individual reader.
If you receive a repayment notice
The audit cannot decide an individual case. SSA's overpayment forms guidance distinguishes three requests according to what the recipient disputes or needs:
| Request | When SSA says to use it |
|---|---|
| Reconsideration, Form SSA-561 | You dispute that an overpayment occurred or believe the amount is wrong. Explain the disagreement. |
| Waiver, Form SSA-632 | You believe you did not cause the overpayment and cannot afford to repay it. |
| Lower recovery rate, Form SSA-634 | You accept repayment but cannot afford the proposed rate. |
SSA says the notice should explain why it believes you were overpaid, the amount and the available response options. Compare that explanation with your benefit and income records before choosing a request. The three forms address different issues; asking for a smaller monthly deduction does not resolve a disagreement over whether the debt exists.
Follow the instructions and deadlines on your notice. SSA directs completed forms to the local Social Security office and lists 1-800-772-1213 for questions, Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 7 p.m.













